Crack Full Length of Living Room Ceiling

Joined
5 Feb 2014
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Location
Cardiff
Country
United Kingdom
Greetings. Sorry that my first post is a question rather than something useful but something has be baffled and I need some help.

So some background first. I live in a top floor flat. 1960s build, metal flat roof that pools terribly when it rains (Im at the highest point and can see the parts of the roof of the "M" shaped building) and when we bought the wreck it had compressed carboard ceiling tiles throughout, most of which were water stained, bowed and even falling down. We took them down and revealed that they were tacked to timber batons (look original and in great condition, nice and dry). Batons are fixed to metal brackets which are fixed to the underside of the flat roof. I wish i'd taken pictures of it, I might have one somewhere.

So, we replaced every ceiling. We had to! Plasterboard screwed to the batons and 'half bonded' like bricks, taped and skimmed then painted. Which makes this all the more confusing. The crack in my ceiling runs the full length of the room, that's almost 7 meters, and because of how the plasterboards are laid out it can't be running along a joint. So, what could be causing this? I'm concerned because it seems to be getting worse. We had a leak last weekend, a small one about 30cm long and maybe 5cm wide, coincidentally along the crack. There was a stain around it too suggesting that it had also happened over the weekend when we were away. I pierced it with a skewer expecting water to dribble out, nothing. No wet patches since despite the worst weather i've seen in ages. Some options i've considered:

Settling/Expansion of the plaster. But there are cracks nowhere else.

Too cold? There is a void of around 30cm (if that) between the plasterboard and underside of the roof.

The plasterboards are heavier than the previous ceiling, and are too much for the batons which are bowing (please God no!)

There is water up there somewhere.

Any suggestions? I'm worried it's going to end up being a big job, that something pretty bad is going to happen. We have spoken to the management committee and a roofer has been called, but they can't get up there until this wind dies down.

I've upload a couple of pictures. Two of the crack which are a bit crap, it's hard to take a picture of it. One of the leak.
//www.diynot.com/network/Designernotdoer/albums/

Cheers everyone!!
 
Sponsored Links
If the battens are fixed to a metal roof why would there not be thermal movement? A sheet metal roof would expand and contract considerably and plasterboard would not begin to be flexible enough to accommodate it
First question is: is the crack parallel or at right angles to the battens? (That assumes that the battening has a particular orientation as far as the fixings are concerned and any battening at right angles can be considered as dwangs or noggins etc.)
 
If the battens are fixed to a metal roof why would there not be thermal movement? A sheet metal roof would expand and contract considerably and plasterboard would not begin to be flexible enough to accommodate it
First question is: is the crack parallel or at right angles to the battens? (That assumes that the battening has a particular orientation as far as the fixings are concerned and any battening at right angles can be considered as dwangs or noggins etc.)

Yes thermal movement id forgotten to mention that. Ive got a picture of before the boards were fixed, ill add that now. Unfortunately I don't have one of the boards unskimmed. The crack is between the edge of the door and the light.
Love to know what you think.
 
Well I wouldn't be that concerned just yet. The battens look plenty strong enough to support the ceiling- can't tell how the metal brackets are secured but a sheet of plasterboard weighs less than 25 KG and if the brackets seemed OK, they probably are. Incidentally, plasterboard bends just fine so "bowed" framing wouldn't cause that. As for water, as you know that causes staining and eventually circular soggy patches- but not neat cracks.
So thermal movement - or just possibly vibration?
I'd be thinking it was a cosmetic issue rather than structural- and be leaving it for a couple of weeks to see how it pans out. :)
 
Sponsored Links
Well I wouldn't be that concerned just yet. The battens look plenty strong enough to support the ceiling- can't tell how the metal brackets are secured but a sheet of plasterboard weighs less than 25 KG and if the brackets seemed OK, they probably are. Incidentally, plasterboard bends just fine so "bowed" framing wouldn't cause that. As for water, as you know that causes staining and eventually circular soggy patches- but not neat cracks.
So thermal movement - or just possibly vibration?
I'd be thinking it was a cosmetic issue rather than structural- and be leaving it for a couple of weeks to see how it pans out. :)

Okay thanks for that :) Ill see what happens, it's been there for a while but gradually getting worse, still only very thin though. It's just got me flummoxed how it's perfectly straight and full length of the room but not along a joint.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top