Small soil pipe through roof tiles

[Martynrbell]

Hi all,
I just had my gutters and soffits replaced this week.
Before the job went ahead I asked for some advice with piping a 21mm pipe out of the loft.
The guy said to take it under a roof tile so the waste goes into the gutter.
The pipe is in there however it looked like there was a big gap now between the tiles so I removed it expecting the tile to lower and the gap to disappear.

Is this normal to see a 2cm gap between the tile?
The one in question is the second row up.

I'm just conscious that the advice was ****e and now I need someone back on the roof to push the tile back into place.

In the other hand its completely normal and I can only see it here because of the new small hole in the felt.
I'll attach a picture of what it looks like from the outside and from the inside.

One image is no flash / one is flash

Thanks for any advice given.

Martyn

 

[datarebal]

to make it sit correctly wit the pipe it needs to be done from outside, tile notched with a small lead saddle. Now even if you seat it correctly without the pipe you will be left with a hole , part of the tile bottom has been chipped off..

 

[Barthy]

I think your man was feeling creative, it happens some times

 

[Martynrbell]

Any advice on whether it's acceptable or not?
Like am I gonna leak
If it was "safe" I was just gonna feed the pipe back through (since the hole is already there) and just lightly stuff the hole with something like insulation or something like that lol .

 

[Barthy]

It's not textbook and kicking tiles accompanied with compromised underlay CAN cause issues but if it doesn't leak I wouldn't lose too much sleep over it.
But if you've had a job carried out and the work is substandard you're well within your rights to expect/want it remedied

 

[datarebal]

If you want things done the right way then it's not ok

 

[Martynrbell]

Quick question chaps.
I have a broken roof tile round the side of my house.
Can anyone say what kind of roof tile that is and where can i get one?

 

[datarebal]

possibly a centurion.. reclaim maybe