Solar - Sunsynk or Givenergy?

Joined
13 Jan 2016
Messages
72
Reaction score
5
Country
United Kingdom
Hi,

I'm considering solar panels (and battery) & have a few quotes lined up, which I have filtered down to 2 companies with similar type equipment & capacities on both the inverter & battery. One is Sunsynk based, and the other is Givenergy.

There are many pros and cons with both;
The Sunsynk is via EDF/Contact Solar and links to a very good tariff - Empower, it's only available if you buy panels etc from EDF.

The Givenergy set up, is designed to work with Octopus Flux tariff. Not as good as EDF, but still worthwhile.

I'm struggling to make a call and wonder if there is anyone on here with experience of either - good or bad?

TIA.
 
Sponsored Links
I fitted solar panels, and it does seem the inverters vary a lot, my main gain is not the solar panels, but the battery that came with the solar panels. So at 1 am I start charging the battery, and at 5 am stop again the house then runs on the battery charged at cheap rate, until the sun comes up, the 3 kW equipment we use, kettle etc, will often use more than we get from solar, but battery fills the gap, so from 5 am to 4 pm most days summer or winter, we use no grid power except for the shower.

The battery will discharge to 10% the last 10% is held to run freezers and central heating in the event of a power cut.

From 4 pm to 1 am often the battery will not last, it is not worth the price of a second battery to ensure it does last, assuming a 7 year life on the battery, so most days we use 3 kWh to recharge the battery overnight, not really needed in summer, but winter it saves us more than the solar panels do, when I went from single tariff all day long to split tariff designed for EV charging, we saw our electric bill drop £20 per month, we had the solar panels Sept last year, smart meter Jan, and split tariff April, and on the BG app we can see the sharp drop in bills once split tariff went live. Before that the battery over winter would some times remain below fully charged for days.

I will admit having an inverter able to do this was some luck, I had ensured it would work as an UPS, but the idea of charging battery over night was an after thought.

The problem, and for me this still exists, is being paid for export, BG offered a very good rate if you buy from them, and SP also do a good rate, but it seems both use a paper application and getting is sorted is a nightmare, Octopus it seems are better, however to give the EV spilt tariff you need to give the charging point and EV vehicle details, BG don't ask for this.

We thought EV tariff and economy 7 would have been the same, but this is not the case, the EV overnight tariff is lower, and the energy companies keep moving the goal posts, when we had it installed we did not need a smart meter, the rules changed the week it was installed, it may not be a law, but now no smart meter = no export payment.

The thing is we only fit solar panels once, so no one can really compare systems. Yesterday was very bad for solar
1725614930586.png

our main gain was battery being charged over night, but day before
1725615028091.png
was more typical, the SOC = state of charge, and you can see the purple line showing the dip 5 am to 7:45 am where the solar was not enough to cover all, then around 9 am started to recharge batteries, and by 11 am fully charged again and 11 am to 5:30 pm we exported excess, (9.2 kWh) then dinner caused a sharp drop, and battery ran out at 11 pm. That is about normal.

So this is the smart meter app display for same day the 4th 1725615627148.png showing charging battery then nothing used until battery down to 10%. Switching to £ it shows how evening cost a lot than morning1725615873752.png due to the rate change. (£1.50 including standing charge)
 
I've whittled down the quotes using a scoring metrics, and the top 2 installers have good reviews. Contact Solar/EDF comes out on top.
Inverter & battery reviews are decent for both makes, however, as usual it's difficult to get a hard & fast decision on either.

I'm slightly erring towards the EDF/Sunsynk system, as the Givenergy is pretty much locked into Octopus.
 
Sponsored Links
I've whittled down the quotes using a scoring metrics, and the top 2 installers have good reviews. Contact Solar/EDF comes out on top.
Inverter & battery reviews are decent for both makes, however, as usual it's difficult to get a hard & fast decision on either.

I'm slightly erring towards the EDF/Sunsynk system, as the Givenergy is pretty much locked into Octopus.

Maybe try a PV forum or a sparks forum as they are the people who really know.

I installed my own PV, but don’t like heights so never offered the service to my customers
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top