OK, found a reference to it, but no manual. It's an open flued boiler so will have no fan and probably no pump overrun, so I can't see why it should need a permanent live. Nevertheless you have identified the permanent live as the source of the live feedback through the switched live. If it does have pump overrun then the pump overrun stat might be faulty.It's definately a 52
The number is 41.315.45
Perhaps someone else will come along who knows this boiler or has a manual and can identify the faulty component. I've got to get some fresh air now - good luck.