I did say do the decent thing and I'm well aware that dishonest John doesn't. I didn't know until now that you do the same.
But the system tells you! It doesn't need us to say so, as well. And how would we say so? By editing the original post, or creating a new one each time?
If you don't read/see the system messages, you can hardly blame anyone else.
I don't want to have to look to the XenForo software to tell me that you have fundamentally changed your post. The edit function is there (IMO) to Add a link or correct spellings etc.
You don't have to look into the software, you just need to read the messages. It's very simple.
It isn't meant to be used to change the context of your post.
It absolutely did not change the context or semantics of the post. I added a couple of comments. The edit function is available to use in any way posters want to use it, not only in the way that you think is acceptable!
And in any case, while it can say you have edited your post it can't say what you have edited.
But you knew anyway. Why does the system need to tell you something which you already know?
I want you to have told me that while I'm reading it.
It is simply not possible, unless you abort your comment, reload the page again, restart your comment over again.
That's the decent thing to do.
Are you the arbiter of all things decent all of a sudden. Perhaps I'll look back for any of your offensive comments.
Edit: If you write one sentence and then decide to go back and add a couple more the decent thing to do is type EDIT: And here's another sentence.
I often do if I think the context or semantics have changed, but not just to add a further comment in the same context.
Just because JD makes a habit of hiding behind the forum software doesn't mean you should.
That's just an offensive, inaccurate poke at another poster.