Hugh,
Agree with you, some of the advice that you have been given by three very knowledgeable people does sound harsh but we feel sure it has been given all in good faith on the limited information given.
Not known. Width, breadth, pitch or roof covering. Assume traditional close coupled cut roof.
Agree with Tuck under felt is not essential, however it is beneficial to have a secondary line of defence.
As roof design is not know Tuck has mentioned A frames. To us A frames are pavement display boards or A frame single storey houses built in heavy snow countries.
Depending on size of area being covered and pitch you will have purlins possibly supported on one or two king post trusses or TDA trusses if house built after 1945.
If you have king post trusses with principal rafters, then dependant on truss centres you could possibly cut ceiling joists out in between to form coupled roof in these sections.
Without a lot of further information, we are not brave enough or silly enough to say any more on the constructional side of your requirements.
However we will quickly add in the following.
Insulation. To achieve current u value of 0.18W/m2k.
Between rafters with 25mm air gap above Celotex XK4000 165mm or between rafters with 25mm air gap above FR4000 75mm with PL4000 62.5 under rafters.
If existing radiators calibrated size wise for existing areas they will not have sufficient out put for increased cubic air value. Ditto possibly your boiler also if working to maximum out put.
If you only have one upstairs room, then partitions are no problem. If you have more than one room, what will you do about increasing height of partitions up into vault?
Also remember all lighting points will need extending.
We have not set out to be negative, but to advise you of the pit falls.
If you go ahead, best of luck, and would suggest you swing a hammock at ceiling level as it will be the warmest part of the room.
oldun