D
Deleted member 174758
This is what happens to an umbrella fixing when properly installed into a hollow plasterboard wall and set using the setting tool:Think the chippy recommended the expanding fixing because of the soft brick.
You can readily see that the type of fixing you are using won't work at all well in solid blockwork because the "umbrella" can't readily open in the block material. The type of fixing below, the Fischer UX (designed for soft blockwork and plasterboard):
does work in the circumstances you are talking about. Is it possible there's been some confusion about which Fischer fixing was being referred to? See Fischer web site for details