I'm guessing that maybe pump was set to 3 as either it needed a bit more oomph due to being old and worn or that the distance to rads warrants it.
House is a large ish 4 bedroom which has also been extended on top of that a couple of times.
Have you checked for pump over?
Do you have a stick? (in-joke
)
I like to identify at the cause of problems before prescribing a solution.
Cure the illness, not treat the symptom.
Your system has worked for years. Now it isn't. What has changed?
Apparently nothing, so something has either worn out or degraded.
So look to see what the corrosion in the sytem is like. Take a rad off, put it in the garden, bung a hose on it, wack it with a soft mallet (Gently) and see what comes out. If its not much, then you could think corrosion isn't an issue.
If it pukes black, you've identified something.
Won't do any harm either to clean them out. I have a system like yours and was astounded at the difference to the system when i removed the rads and flushed them out. Took me about 2hrs to remove and refit a dozen of them.
I then added cleaner for a fortnight and the system now behaves very well.
If you are handy, you could remove the pump and inspect the impeller, clean it up and its casing if required. If its bad, you could fit a modern pump which are stronger than the older ones anyway so you'd probably be fine on speed 1 tbh.
Bung in cleaner which will help the boiler he/ex and the indirect coils, flush, job done.
It isn't difficult. You've a vented system (clean out the head tank as well). Think of it as an annual service