Usage in Sep-Dec 2011 (89 days) was 6,383.03. Usage Sep-Dec 2012 (88 days) 9,912.21
just checked that. As you are quoting kWh per quarter I presume you are reading it off your gas bill. Actual meter readings would be nice.
9912kWh in 88 days is 112kWh per day so your meter should be recording nearly 10 cu metres average per day. Is that right for the meter readings? What is the meter showing per day this week, or, since you last took a reading?
In icy weather I can get through 78kWh per day (that was my January average usage) but December was 73 and (unusually cold) November was 55
I realise you have an old house with solid walls (no cavity insulation) but mine is bigger than yours. I'm on the South Coast, where are you?
How deep is the loft insulation?
If you measure your radiators and add all their length together (count doubles as 1.5) how much length of radiators have you got? Are they 600mm tall, or what?
Is the ground floor carpeted, or bare boards?
What are your windows and doors like? Draughty wood?
Do you have any open fireplaces?
edit
p.s.
I just checked my 2011 and 2012 usages
2011
October 49.6 cu metres
November 106 cu.m
December 198 cu.m
2012
October 83.7 cu.m
November 152 cu.m
December 205 cu.m
so, like you, my 2012 usage is significantly more than my 2011.
I account for it by the cold weather. Nothing else has changed.