Sorry Sparkymarka but I think JohnD is right. Any half-decent battery charging circuit should charged the battery at constant current until the battery approaches full capacity and then change to constant voltage. The amount of current supplied in the first phase depends on the size of the battery. This means that a much bigger battery may never reach the changeover point and may be float charged at too high a voltage.
This shouldn't be too much of a problem if the new bettery is a size bigger but I wouldn't want to replace a 2.1 AHr with a 17AHr!
This shouldn't be too much of a problem if the new bettery is a size bigger but I wouldn't want to replace a 2.1 AHr with a 17AHr!