So stop saying they don't allow it.
Shamima was smuggled in by WESTERN inteligence!
- Thread starter gasbusters
- Start date
- Status
Sponsored Links
I saw my Bangladeshi friend last night. He has children just below 21 and one at 22, so he has been through this recently and knows the rules. His children are Bangladeshi citizens. He confirmed they gain that automatically because he is a Bangladeshi citizen himself. His 22 year old Son applied for citizenship when he reached 21 and got it. There are no tricky questions, it is just a formality. The reason is purely practical. They have family in Bangladesh and it just makes it easier to visit. The law is complex and possibly contradictory but this aspect seems clear to me.
I would think the more important thing is the humanitarian issue of the girl being cast adrift. What she did was wrong and I don't accept spurious arguments about being groomed and not knowing what she was up to. She clearly knew what she was doing, and it wasn't spur of the moment. You don't just pack a bag and randomly meet a human trafficker on your doorstep. She clearly researched and planned the trip and knew exactly what she was getting into.
I personally think she approached this wrongly in the first place. Initially she had no remorse and stood by her actions. If she had put her hands up and shown remorse I think things may have turned out differently for her.
I would think the more important thing is the humanitarian issue of the girl being cast adrift. What she did was wrong and I don't accept spurious arguments about being groomed and not knowing what she was up to. She clearly knew what she was doing, and it wasn't spur of the moment. You don't just pack a bag and randomly meet a human trafficker on your doorstep. She clearly researched and planned the trip and knew exactly what she was getting into.
I personally think she approached this wrongly in the first place. Initially she had no remorse and stood by her actions. If she had put her hands up and shown remorse I think things may have turned out differently for her.
I have consistently said that the law does not allow dual citizenship, but the government may grant exceptions.
Just like UK law does not allow violence, but may grant exceptions.
She was 15 and impressionable.
it’s not a spurious argument, it’s just fact that she was groomed.
I rather doubt somebody rang her up one day and said “hey do you fancy going to Syria to chop the heads off a few people”.
Sponsored Links
Does he, or they have dual citizenship?
They can have Bangladeshi citizenship, but not dual citizenship, and have permanent leave to remain in UK.
Or their application for citizenship, and thus dual citizenship, was allowed as an exception, which they had to apply for. It's not an automatic entitlement. It may appear automatic because it wasn't problematic, but Bangladesh are perfectly within their rights and law to refuse their application unless they revoked their UK citizenship.
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 17,558
- Reaction score
- 2,412
- Country
It is for those under 21.
It isn't and I have provided a fair bit of legal evidence that it is not.
Can anyone provide indisputable evidence that dual citizenship is allowed for minors?
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 17,558
- Reaction score
- 2,412
- Country
I've posted it several times now.
"However, it is abundantly clear that Ms Begum is legally a citizen of Bangladesh until she attains the age of 21 years. Thus, the claims of the Government of Bangladesh and some others that Ms Begum is not a Bangladeshi citizen owing to the fact that she does not hold a Bangladeshi passport or any other proof of citizenship, has never submitted any application for dual nationality, and has never visited Bangladesh, have no legal basis."
Shamima Begum may be a Bangladeshi Citizen After All
In 2015, Ms Shamima Begum, then a 15-year-old British citizen living in London, travelled to Syria to join the so-called Islamic State. Her fate was unknown until recently when Ms Begum was discovered in a refugee camp in Syria. On 19 February 2019, the British Home Office in a letter delivered...
www.ejiltalk.org
- Joined
- 22 Aug 2006
- Messages
- 5,884
- Reaction score
- 728
- Country
At first it appears She's Brit cos she was born here (assuming she was) and she's Bangladeshi as a right, through blood, though Bangla does NOT normally allow dual nationality. They make up the rules as they go along, currently allowing applications from peoiple born here of a Bangla parent.
It's certainly not clear.
It's certainly not clear.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 17,558
- Reaction score
- 2,412
- Country
Bangladeshi law,
She is not yet 21 so can have dual nationality.
"14. (l) Subject to the provisions of this section if any person is a citizen of Bangladesh under the provisions of this Act, and is at the same time a citizen or national of any other country, he shall, unless he makes a declaration according to the laws of that other country renouncing his status as citizen or national thereof, cease to be a citizen of Bangladesh.
(1A) Nothing in sub-section (1) applies to a person who has not attained twenty-one years of his age."
Link?
Your own source disputes your claim:I've posted it several times now.
"However, it is abundantly clear that Ms Begum is legally a citizen of Bangladesh until she attains the age of 21 years. Thus, the claims of the Government of Bangladesh and some others that Ms Begum is not a Bangladeshi citizen owing to the fact that she does not hold a Bangladeshi passport or any other proof of citizenship, has never submitted any application for dual nationality, and has never visited Bangladesh, have no legal basis."
Shamima Begum may be a Bangladeshi Citizen After All
In 2015, Ms Shamima Begum, then a 15-year-old British citizen living in London, travelled to Syria to join the so-called Islamic State. Her fate was unknown until recently when Ms Begum was discovered in a refugee camp in Syria. On 19 February 2019, the British Home Office in a letter delivered...www.ejiltalk.org
From your link
Seems abundantly clear to me.
Additionally, because she affirmed (by conduct) allegiance to another (hostile) state, she is disqualified from Bangladeshi citizenship.
Again from your link.
Last edited:
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 17,558
- Reaction score
- 2,412
- Country
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2007
- Messages
- 17,558
- Reaction score
- 2,412
- Country
Of course they'll claim that, so what? The law is clear.
Evidently, it's not clear, as recognised in your link:
From your link.
Hence my long time assertion that only Bangladesh can interpret its own laws.
- Status
Sponsored Links