They deserve a........

[Scarlet Pimpernel]

Fortunately your opinion doesn't carry much weight.

I wouldn't be surprised if there was a referendum for hanging, that a majority would vote to bring back hanging.
Funny how politicians pick and choose on which issues to be a representative politician, and on others they decide to be a trustee politician.
I guess it all depends which ones are the most likely to result in them being re-elected.

 

[Scarlet Pimpernel]

Repeat offenders who murder, would seem to average 3 per year over this 10 year period.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-16638227

So over the time line of your suspects, this would equate to roughly 210 murders, from repeat offenders.

Not a fan of capital punishment, but all murderers should face life in jail, with no parole.

You don't think that factors such as age, mental health, motivation, previous history, coercion, etc should be considered?

 

[Trazor]

You don't think that factors such as age, mental health, motivation, previous history, coercion, etc should be considered?

If we take all your considerations into account, what proportion of those 210 murders would you deem as acceptable?

 

[transam]

No surprises there.


Fortunately your opinion doesn't carry much weight.


You don't seem to understand the difference between punishment and retribution.


No surprises there.

neither does yours

Yes I do

 

[JohnD]

So over the time line of your suspects, this would equate to roughly 210 murders, from repeat offenders.

none of the people in my list are murderers, or repeat offenders, or suspects.

They are all people who were wrongly convicted.

At least one of them went barmy as a result.

Some were executed, some died in jail.

 

[JohnD]

If we take all your considerations into account, what proportion of those 210 murders would you deem as acceptable?

or, since they are all non-murderers, what proportion of non-murders?

And how many non-murderers are you happy to execute?

 

[johnny2007]

What would they say to the family of a person posthumously cleared of a crime?
Would they actually be prepared to kill an offender themselves, or would they happily pass the job on to a state executioner?

Capital punishment should be applied when there's no doubt whatsoever about guilt.
For example when a criminal is caught killing someone in presence of many people and arrested on the spot.
Or when there are already strong evidence and they immediately admit the crime.
Capital punishment only when there's 100% certainty of guilt.
I believe the 3 shyts have proudly admitted their crime, so off to the beating by the old man family if they wish and if they survive give them 10 years hard labour, permanently chained up, without any parole, no tv, no playstation, a few potatoes a day and a chicken leg once a month.

 

[Trazor]

none of the people in my list are murderers, or repeat offenders, or suspects.

Never said they were, you lie in order to obfuscate, your'e getting adept at twisting words and lying.

 

[Trazor]

or, since they are all non-murderers, what proportion of non-murders?

And how many non-murderers are you happy to execute?

More lies, taken totally out of context, I would rather trust Boris than you.

EDIT: I would rather trust Donald Trump than you.

Why didn't your Alter Ego reply to me.........

"Mottie doesn't care"

 

[JohnD]

lies

That would be you, describing my list of innocent people, wrongly convicted, as "suspects."

 

[JohnD]

your suspects

they are not suspects, and you are wrong to describe them as such.

 

[transam]

or, since they are all non-murderers, what proportion of non-murders?

And how many non-murderers are you happy to execute?

well one non murderer who would be executed

will be that bloke who threw that little french boy off that roof

all others would be executed on a case by case basis

for example were there is no doubt as to there guilt

that bloke who stabbed joe cox
Those 2 blokes who beheaded that soldier

that bloke who kidnapped raped tortured and killed that little 6 year old girl in Scotland

they would all be dispensed with and good riddance to bad rubbish

 

[transam]

Let all of them be put in fear of there lives

let that Scottish fruit cake beg for his life like that little girl did

crying for her mum and dad as she was subjected to torture with over 100 injuries on her body

I would not hesitate to execute that peice of rubbish not for an instant would I hesitate

 

[Scarlet Pimpernel]

If we take all your considerations into account, what proportion of those 210 murders would you deem as acceptable?

Strawman argument. I didn't suggest nor intimate that any murder is acceptable.
I don't consider responding to strawman arguments to be urgent.

 

[transam]

Another one would be that fruit cake who killed all those people on that island in Norway

he would stop breathing as well

and those two girls who tortured that elderly woman to death

they would be bumped off on there 18th birthdays