Woke act comes in to force in Scotland

[Stivino]

Not much point in reporting something that occurred before the law came into force.

I think their point is that, Mr Yousless wants to introduce a law that will benefit him.
I've got to watch what I say as I might be accused of a hate crime.

 

[motorbiking]

Not much point in reporting something that occurred before the law came into force.

You've not really got your head around this concept of aggravated by prejudice. There is no time limit on the "single source". Historic sources would do just fine.

 

[motorbiking]

Quite a funny thread:

https://twitter.com/x/status/1774749954629652873

 

[Odds]

We do not have similar laws in England and Wales.

In England and Wales a person is free to be prejudiced against Jews and transgender for example without these being counted as aggravating factors should they be accused of a public order offence.

There is a big difference between having hate as a motive and simply being prejudiced.

But it's not a long stretch between acting upon the prejudice with hate, given the circumstances: such as the rise in anti-semitic and anti-muslim sentiment as the war in Gaza has progressed.

 

[motorbiking]

I think people may be misunderstanding the mitigation/aggravating concepts in criminal law.

A - commits a crime against another - the sentence is X

A - has mitigating circumstances - e.g. provocation. the sentence is X - Y
A - has aggravating circumstances - e.g. hate motivation. the sentence is X + Y

The new Scotland legislation removes mitigation and allows prejudice (even historic) to be an aggravating factor.

 

[Odds]

Historic prejudice will seriously compromise the simple joy of slanging songs back n' forth at the next England-Scotland international.

 

[gant]

Will this be the end of the word sassenach being used in public and private circles?

 

[Odds]

Are Jethro Tull allowed to play 'Pibroch' now or is that 'cultural appropriation'?

 

[gant]

Will they be able to play the sex pistols on the juke box in pub.

 

[Odds]

Friggin' in the riggin'?

 

[gant]

Bet there's a few tasty things said on Burns night.

"Whom the gods wish to destroy they first make mad"

 

[gas112]

Rangers /celtic game this weekend take it the cops will be visiting all the watering holes saying excuse me but you cant be screaming that at the telly

 

[carmanmemoranda]

You've not really got your head around this concept of aggravated by prejudice. There is no time limit on the "single source". Historic sources would do just fine.

Not what the real legal bods are saying

 

[noseall]

Not what the real legal bods are saying

MBK is not very savvy with the law.

 

[motorbiking]

Oh look dumb and dumber making a contribution... oh wait... just trolling again.

If you have legal opinion and source. lets see it.