CH Energy Requirements Estimate

The discussions in this thread, and my associated one (click here), have been very interesting and thought-provoking but have not yet really answered the question I posed in my OP, basically asking how reasonable/credible people felt my heat-loss calculations were. In particular, the one response above which was addressing that question, was somewhat vague, namely ...
11kw sounds massively out
I would be very interested to know in which direction gas112 felt that my calculations were 'massively out', and hence in what ballpark he would have expected the answer to be.

To remind you all, I am talking about a fairly large late Victorian 3-storey mid-terraced house, with a total floor area of about 110 m²). Other than for the pitched roof, it’s fairly poorly insulated, with solid 9” brick external walls, single-glazed wooden-framed windows and a suspended wooden ground floor. It is a 'narrow but deep' house - some 5m x 17m overall, hence with relatively little in the way of outside walls, and the two adjacent properties are occupied and heated.

My initial heat-loss calculations suggested a total heat energy requirement (for space heating alone) of around 11 kW, with most rooms requiring a radiator of around 1.5 kW. I have subsequently re-visited those calculations with various alterations to the assumptions, and the 'worst case' of these suggests a total of 13-14 kW, with rooms most commonly needing radiators in the ballpark of 1.5-2.0 kW.

The question of how I translate estimated radiator heat outputs into radiator size (depending upon flow temp and delta T) has been (and continues to be) discussed at length in the other thread.

So, retuning to my initial question, I wonder if people feel that (given the nature of the property) my heat-loss calculations for this house are reasonable/credible - and, if not, roughly what they would have expected the total heat-loss (hence radiator requirements) to be?

Kind Regards, John
 
Sponsored Links
I have been going through this myself and I have used Heatpunk to calculate my heat loss. It is very comprehensive.
 
I have been going through this myself and I have used Heatpunk to calculate my heat loss. It is very comprehensive.
There are umpteen calculators out there, varying from the pretty simplistic (essentially just looking at floor area or room volume) to the much ore sophisticated, and I've tried many of them. However, the variation between the results they give is so great that quite frankly, I'm more inclined to trust my own, pretty 'comprehensive' calculations 'from first principles - at least I know how those calculation have been done :)

However, as we have been discussing in the other thread, this whole exercise takes on a different light when one realised that the radiators that would be needed to satisfy the calculations for an 'optimally efficient' heating system (delta T of 30, or maybe even 20 degrees) are usually 'impractically large' to be installed in a domestic property!

Kind Regards, John
 
As long as your ceilings are between 7'6" and 8'6" 11kW sounds fine in traditional calculations.

If you're running a heat pump 24/7 maybe a little lower.
 
Sponsored Links
As long as your ceilings are between 7'6" and 8'6" 11kW sounds fine in traditional calculations.
Many thanks. The ceilings in the upper two floors are below 8'8", but those on the ground floor are slightly over 9' - but I p[resume that will not make a very big difference to what you are saying, particularly given that I will definitely 'add a margin' onto the calculated heat output requirements.
If you're running a heat pump 24/7 maybe a little lower.
I'm definitely not contemplating a heat pump. However, even if I were I don't think that would alter the amount of heat output required from the radiators - but, because of the lower temps, would have a massive effect on the size of radiator required to achieve those heat outputs - as I've said, seemingly to the extent of requiring radiators which would probably usually/often be 'impractically large' in a domestic setting. I'm therefore not sure what those wanting to use heat pump[s are meant to do!

Kind Regards, John
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top