- Joined
- 28 Oct 2005
- Messages
- 31,281
- Reaction score
- 1,997
- Country
JulieL/B said:oilman said:All men masturbate,
Errr.........no they don't!
If they can - they do. I can.
joe
JulieL/B said:oilman said:All men masturbate,
Errr.........no they don't!
oilman said:hermes said:..........
Stop trying to put words into my mouth. I don't really care either way what happens to Cliff's royalties.
Stop making unjustified inferences. You made the statement "Laws are not always right" I asked you a question. Simple.
joe-90 said:JulieL/B said:oilman said:All men masturbate,
Errr.........no they don't!
If they can - they do. I can.
joe
JulieL/B said:joe-90 said:JulieL/B said:oilman said:All men masturbate,
Errr.........no they don't!
If they can - they do. I can.
joe
Well, bully for you!
Quite frankly, I really don't think that anyone here is intersted in whether you ma*******e or not.
The statement was ALL men do it.........my point is - not ALL of them do!
Even the most sh*tty table has a functional value, but we've been talking about monetary value hermes.hermes said:If tables had no value there would be no tables.
And a CD has value when it's in its case, like a table has value even when you're not sitting at it.hermes said:Music has value if people enjoy it, even if it is just a few lines on a sheet in your hand or a few notes in someones head.
However, the system that allows laws to be created and changed is right, so what do you do to change the laws that you think are wrong?hermes said:Laws are not always right.
Again, this is not a moral dilemma. It's interesting that all of the analogies that are being drawn are highly emotive, e.g. war, slavery, Council Tax - do you really believe that the number of pennies from the sale of a CD, or the playing of a track in public, that end up in Cliff's hands is as important an issue to be Christian about as whether or not Tony Blair should be allowed to get away with the illegal decision to send professional killers to another country?hermes said:I was responding to softus saying that it is right to observe copyright for 50 years because it is the law. I was merely saying that just because something is law doesn't mean it is right. It used to be legal to keep slaves. Is that right?
Gotcha I think tonight might be my lucky night.paulbrown said:If you were IN you wouldn't need to be a wkr.
Music has value if people enjoy it, even if it is just a few lines on a sheet in your hand or a few notes in someones head.
And a CD has value when it's in its case, like a table has value even when you're not sitting at it.