I regularly get water damaged old L&P ceilings in [generally] Tenement flats where the ceiling has to be removed, that is the old lime horsehair plaster AND the laths !! i always specify a double board of plasterboard, not simply for the fire separation aspect, but to account for the thickness of the old plaster.
For several years, I worked in listed property, all owned by the Government, traditional L&P was a really, really scarce to find as a material of choise when renovating, L&P was never replaced on a like for like basis, Plasterboard was the go to option.
I did have one domestic flood damaged property where the owner demanded L&P be replaced on a like for like basis then complained long and loud because of a three to four month wait for the plasterers to complete the L&P aspect of the work.
Ken
For several years, I worked in listed property, all owned by the Government, traditional L&P was a really, really scarce to find as a material of choise when renovating, L&P was never replaced on a like for like basis, Plasterboard was the go to option.
I did have one domestic flood damaged property where the owner demanded L&P be replaced on a like for like basis then complained long and loud because of a three to four month wait for the plasterers to complete the L&P aspect of the work.
Ken