pickles said:
The difference between Hezbollah and the IRA is that the IRA only wanted the british out of Ireland not England as well, if they had we would all still be fighting and the things you suggest would be appropriate to what would be a total war. Hezbollah want's Israel out of Israel, so there's not much room for negotiating, hence the endlees bombs and bullets.
I think that the Israeli view is that since there is no one to persuade or reason with militarily or politically all they have is military options and no reason to moralise about civilians who get in the way. They are engaged in a war of political and ethnic extermination more akin to the Russian war with Germany in the second world war than the conflict with the IRA.
There is no such thing as a civilian in the middle east.
I'm not very clear as to what Hezbollah's real aim is. Some say that they do not want Israel out of Israel, but Israel out of the disputed territories seized by Israel.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah
Maybe they even want the repatriation of the Palestinian people with a self-governed Palestinian homeland.
Others may well say Hezbollah's main aim is to remove Israel from the map. Unfortunately, there are serious axes to grind on many sides and we usually won't hear the truth, whatever that may be. Each side wishes to demonise the other and portray their own course of actions as the only reasonable option in the circumstances.
It appears to me that maybe Ariel Sharon, whose past is not without censure, may have taken a huge step towards a lasting peace with plans to withdraw from disputed territories unilaterally, before his untimely ill-health.
Now we appear to be going backwards with certain countries stirring the pot, as others have rightly said.
I still believe a two state solution is the way forward and ultimately this has to happen or we will continue with potentially escalating violence in the region and spread abroad.
pickles said:
What's also interesting is the silence of arab governments. There is a historic rivalry between arabs eg, Egyptians and Persians, ie the Iranians, many people in power in the arab world see this conflict as the devil fighting the devil and see an outcome in which Hezbollah loose and Israel gets a hiding in the process as the perfect outcome
I agree about the Arab governments apparent silence. With the right intentions they could play a major role in brokering a peace, as could America. Why they don't appear to be doing so is sad.
As you rightly say, there are many rivalries especially between Shi'ites and Sunnis but also many very unstable or dictatorial states don't help.