Mmmm.... But what are we to do when so much of the "opposing view" is actually ignorant people regurgitating the lies that they read in the popular press?david and julie said:If you want those things that is for you. Many pro euro people would probably want the same.
The problem is we live in a democracy which is being hi-jacked and any opposing view is being ignored.
If we had a referendum on bringing back the death penalty, it would probably be voted in. But that wouldn't make it right.Before anything on this scale is contemplated our views should be sought.
Dear God - now what? What wording of yours have I changed?Incidently your subtle changing of my wording didn't go unnoticed.
ban-all-sheds said:Mmmm.... But what are we to do when so much of the "opposing view" is actually ignorant people regurgitating the lies that they read in the popular press?
If we had a referendum on bringing back the death penalty, it would probably be voted in. But that wouldn't make it right.
No, no, and a thousand times NO! Being in the majority does not make you right, and being in the minority does not make you wrong.AdamW said:If it is voted in through a national referendum, this reflects the feelings of the people who voted at that moment in time, it is therefore right. Your opinion is that it would be wrong, and you are entitled to that opinion. But, in this situation you would be in the minority and therefore less correct than those who voted in the majority.
ban-all-sheds said:No, no, and a thousand times NO! Being in the majority does not make you right, and being in the minority does not make you wrong.
If a majority of people thought that the earth was flat, would that make them right?
If a majority of people thought that 2+2=5, would that make them right?
you would be in the minority and therefore less correct than those who voted in the majority.
OK - apologies - I'll change my comment to "being in the majority does not make you more correct than the minority". And I'm afraid there are also instances where it does not make your opinion more important than the minority.AdamW said:If you read my post properly you will understand. You will note that I actually said:
you would be in the minority and therefore less correct than those who voted in the majority.
A very interesting interesting existential debate, but I'm concerned with the real world, and in the real world that's bo||ocks.And my reference to 1984 was along the same lines as your "Earth is flat" argument. In the book, the interrogator says something along the lines of "What are stars? We say they are balls of fire a few kilometres up.". The point is, that is right because the people who have the power said it is.
That's bo||ocks too. Society may decide to do what the majority want, even though it is wrong, but doing it does not make it right.In the case of a referendum, the proletariat hold the power (influence is another debate). Therefore, if they say something is right, it is.
More bo||ocks.However, the Earth is flat, that is a fact. We can prove that.
Of course I can't prove that it is wrong - I can advance all sorts of logical and moral arguments as to why it is wrong, but if, ultimately, someone is such a stupid and bloodthirsty savage that they do not see that it is wrong then there's nothing I can do, except to hope that their opinion is ignored.But, taking your example of the death penalty, prove to me that the it is wrong.
The death penalty is wrong. People who cannot see that are wrong. Their opinion counts for nothing, no matter how widely it is held.And without the "you prove to me it is right" argument. You can't. You can offer your opinion it is wrong. You might draw on religious books, you might refer to works of great philosophers. You might even show that it is illogical to put someone to death when they are a perfectly good source of labour. However, your opinion is just that: an opinion.
I don't give a toss. As far as the aspect of the death penalty is concerned, people who are in favour of it are worth less than dogshyt on the sole of my shoe.No matter how convinced you are, people will oppose you.