Many electricians don't worry about colours so impossible to give 100% answer.
There are just 3 wires and two really important so two main wires go to pins 2 and 5 and once connected the dial tone is heard. The third connects to pin 4 and works the bell. If bell doesn't work swap 2 and 5 around.
Pins 1, 3, and 6 are not used. For computers and powered telephones (cordless) the pin 4 is often not required. Many telephones will still work if 2 and 5 are wrong way around some it does matter which has resulted in many a argument as to if phone is faulty where borrowed phone works so one assumes phone is faulty and in fact 2 and 5 are swapped.
Got your 3 and 4 mixed up Eric
Also, if you mix your 2+5 up after the the NTE, and have the ring wire correctly connected, you can get continuous ring when the phones are on hook. Not all phones need the ringer (3), but you should connected it through.