Bypass when using Grundfos Alpha2 pump

DC controlled pumps will do squat for HX that buckle at the drop of a hat.

The purpose for which you bought your PC is irrelevant. Send your contribution, interesting thought is will do nothing fro UK energy efficiency.

Such is the way of things.
 
Sponsored Links
Hi all
Forgive me if I have missed anything or repeated anything as i'm not too well at the mo but just read most of the thread with interest and have to say most of you have raised some valid points
I work in the commercial sector and bar destrat pumps,UFH pumps and secondary return pumps all the others modulate, including shunt pumps but most of the systems I work with are BMS/PLC controlled and as agile pointed out earlier, low loss headers are always involved mind you IIRC some viessman boilers modulate their pumps as standard
smokebox there are many solutions to your problems it depends how sofhisticated you want them to be, because as agile has pointed out in a domestic situation it might just not be worth it

you could use a plc/bms to operate the system
you could use pressure transducers to operate a proportional valve
you could use temp sensors to do the same
you could, as you say use a relay to operate a valve
you could use a relay solution to keep one of your existing valves open while the system is in overrun
etc
I will draw you a circuit if req

ps dan do you mean a momo valve or mimo ?

Matt

Some interesting and helpful observations, though some of the trade abbreviations are beyond me. When I said MIMO i was trying to talk of a presettable but fixed flow valve, such as I linked to earlier by Taconova. I was just copying Dan Robinson who is a I think a professional. What does MIMO or indeed MOMO stand for or mean.?

Minimal sophistication would be the target! They've got to get correctly installed somehow!

I get the feeling you are working on much bigger stuff and much more "industrial"? I guess in houses minimal capital outlay must be a high priority. I am sure Agile talks slightly provocatively good sense, but LLHs etc seem over the top to me in the common or garden house when a small solenoid operated valve would do the job , I think , with no fancy control needed and near exactly cover the requirement of stopping bypass full stop in ordinary running, when the boiler is safely unloading heat to rads or cylinders, while at the same time more or less instantly opening to protect heat exchanger on zone closure. The smart pump quietly gets on with its job, no loss of condensing potential, and the Heat exchanger is protected at zone closure in the pump overrun..

Am I missing something.?

Many of the commentators seem rather resistant to this notion, without exactly saying why!

Actually your idea of holding an existing zone open for pump overun duration has just sunk in and appeals to me - it may be cheapest as well!

Thank you for fresh perspective, and I hope your health is improving. I might take you up on the circuit offer if I am in trouble! Thanks very much.

smokebox
 
DC controlled pumps will do squat for HX that buckle at the drop of a hat.

The purpose for which you bought your PC is irrelevant. Send your contribution, interesting thought is will do nothing fro UK energy efficiency.

Such is the way of things.

What a cynic!
Cheer up
 
All these things may seem very simple to you!

However, you could dwell overnight on just how you are going to get a logic output from the boiler which is only activated SOLELY when pump over run is required.

To help get you started I will point out that the boiler only gives an output when ( all ) pump activation is required.

Just in case you dont understand that, it might be for 74 minutes while calling for heat followed by say 6 minutes of over run.

The nupty installer is not bothered by any of that and is just presented with a 230v supply labelled "pump" for 80 minutes !


Your task, if you choose to accept, is to devise a solution to provide an output for the 6 minutes of pump overun ONLY !

If you fail to provide a correct answer by 1200 hrs on 12-10-2011 then you will self destruct !



Rules:-

No bunnies are permitted to enter ( or leave ).

No Mickies, Eco Warriors, Chris Rs or Gas Gurus are permitted ( or anyone else with a degree in electronics! )

No Grundfos employees or their MD ( who are now watching ) may enter!
 
Sponsored Links
You have a strange viewpoint of the industry, but not totally uninformed (often more dangerous than no knowledge at all).

Your plumber is probably under-qualified, under-experienced and worried about not being paid. He has possibly bought an entire boiler to hold as spares in order to supply your new HX.

Even so, if such a minor error of installation could actually cause this type of damage to a HX then I sure as hell wouldn't want one in my house.

Think about it. This is a pretty minor error on the part of the installer and should in no way have caused HX failure after a few months (I am assuming) or operation.

Shoddy manufacturer IMO.

I don't really agree all this Dan. I had his specification of boiler size, which he estimated by eyeballing the house. He was happy with a Vaillant 428 ecoTEC plus, and he was happy with a smart pump.
I think the boiler was oversized, but I like to be sure myself in the coming cold ++! and I may be extending the heating to a free standing garage largely uninsulated. I suspect but have not yet proven the pump was undersized.

He clearly knew about bypasses and brought one with him! But he rendered it ineffective by setting it well above the top pressure of the pump altogether, let alone the smart zone peak. He was never a great man on paper work and diagrams. He was somewhat out of his depth I now realize. His electrician compounded the issue by miswiring and haughtily dismissing my concerns, so no pump overrun. The plumber trusted him implicitly but mistakenly. These are not trivial mistakes in my book.

Now how can a Heat exchanger stand all that! You may not like Vaillant, and there are issues mainly with technical advice and help. I think they are well constructed and many heating engineers swear by them. Views differ, but whatever boiler you're using, you've got to install it correctly.

A gas flame of 28 kW WILL leave hot spots in the HE pipe work if there is zero circulation at zone closure. Temps are very very high for a short time and bangs and damage does not surprise me. Actually the temp of the burning gas will be the same at 5kw as 28kW of course but one feels risks are higher on abrupt withdrawal of 28kW!

I don't really think it is the boilers fault!! Its abuse!

smokebox
 
All these things may seem very simple to you!

However, you could dwell overnight on just how you are going to get a logic output from the boiler which is only activated SOLELY when pump over run is required.

To help get you started I will point out that the boiler only gives an output when ( all ) pump activation is required.

Just in case you dont understand that, it might be for 74 minutes while calling for heat followed by say 6 minutes of over run.

The nupty installer is not bothered by any of that and is just presented with a 230v supply labelled "pump" for 80 minutes !

Your task, if you choose to accept, is to devise a solution to provide an output for the 6 minutes of pump overun ONLY !

If you fail to provide a correct answer by 1200 hrs on 12-10-2011 then you will self destruct !



Rules:-

No bunnies are permitted to enter ( or leave ).

No Mickies, Eco Warriors, Chris Rs or Gas Gurus are permitted ( or anyone else with a degree in electronics! )

No Grundfos employees or their MD ( who are now watching ) may enter!

Agile you are a hard man - I'll check your story about timing of power supply to and from the pump and boiler tomorrow and have a lonesome crack at the matter, but am worried about getting drawing uploaded onto the thread. I wonder if it is possible? (either task) Am I allowed to get help from the dog?!!!

Good night
smokebox
 
Thank you for fresh perspective, and I hope your health is improving. I might take you up on the circuit offer if I am in trouble! Thanks very much.

smokebox

Hi smokebox and thanks
yes i'm more commercial/ industrial and your problem would easily be resolved via plc in my usual domain as it would be nothing more than a programming issue
My health probs will hopefully improve as I've nothing more than a heavy cold/virus/bug (still feel like sh1t though) but thanks for asking

yes no probs with a circuit, I'm sure I could knock something simple up, it would probably only involve a relay or two

Matt

Ps MOMO = motor open motor close
MIMO = I havn't a clue what it stands for
 
Thank you for fresh perspective, and I hope your health is improving. I might take you up on the circuit offer if I am in trouble! Thanks very much.

smokebox

Hi smokebox and thanks
yes i'm more commercial/ industrial and your problem would easily be resolved via plc in my usual domain as it would be nothing more than a programming issue
My health probs will hopefully improve as I've nothing more than a heavy cold/virus/bug (still feel like s**t though) but thanks for asking

yes no probs with a circuit, I'm sure I could knock something simple up, it would probably only involve a relay or two

Matt

Ps MOMO = motor open motor close
MIMO = I havn't a clue what it stands for

Agile has given me a task! See preceding post. Do you think you are excluded from assisting?
If I get stuck what is the procedure to contact contrbutor privately safely and secretly? Seriously is there a method? I am new to all this sort of thing.

Smokebox
 
However, you could dwell overnight on just how you are going to get a logic output from the boiler which is only activated SOLELY when pump over run is required.

you don't need an individual logic output from the boiler as such tony (would make things a lot easier though), you already have enough logic outputs as it is
you have a logic state when the boiler is in demand you can pick up and use
you have a logic state from the boiler when the pump is running you can pick up and use
you have a logic on state from the individual controls (stats) you can use if needed
and not forgetting
you have a logic off state from the individual controls (stats) you can use if needed

To help get you started I will point out that the boiler only gives an output when ( all ) pump activation is required.
And thats one logic state you will be using
Your task, if you choose to accept, is to devise a solution to provide an output for the 6 minutes of pump overun ONLY !

If you fail to provide a correct answer by 1200 hrs on 12-10-2011 then you will self destruct !

puts me out of the competition as the bourne identity has just finished and I'm going to bed now and at work tommorrow so I'll miss the deadline
 
Agile has given me a task! See preceding post. Do you think you are excluded from assisting?
If I get stuck what is the procedure to contact contrbutor privately safely and secretly? Seriously is there a method? I am new to all this sort of thing.

Smokebox

I'm sure if you are ok with relay circuits you will cope Smokebox
as for the method, I have never had to do it but from first glance I would say yes no probs
I'm out gigging tomorrow night but if I get some free time tomorrow I will see what I can come up with

Matt
 
The burner is not firing during pump overrun!

As regards Tony's question about three valves:

If you use the boiler I have in mind, it has a built-in diverter valve, so that eliminates a 2 valve [S Plan] setup. You can add up to two mixers controlled by the weather comp in the boiler, one of which can be a Sub Mounting Kit with Mixer, in a matching casing underneath.

If you stop and think about heating controls, you can see that heat requirement varies inversely with outside temperature, and weather compensation matches this automatically.

Otherwise, you can go out from the heating circs to an external mid-position [Y Plan] valve to feed either or both of two heating circuits [remember, the hot water is controlled by the diverter valve within the boiler]. There will then be a port always open for pump overrun.
 
Matt and MM have both given hints on how you could ( at first sight ) deduce a logical output when the pump is in over run.

External assistance was not intended or hoped for but will certainly be of very great help to you.

The objective is to derive a signal to be used to open a solenoid valve to produce the required pump over run.

There is no reason why that should not totally protect the boiler by providing the required bypass flow.

But this would be a non standard method and probably hardly understood by anyone connected with Vaillant. It might not be sufficient to convince them the boiler is correctly installed and thus entitled to a warrantee.

Tony
 
He clearly knew about bypasses and brought one with him! But he rendered it ineffective by setting it well above the top pressure of the pump altogether, let alone the smart zone peak. He was never a great man on paper work and diagrams. He was somewhat out of his depth I now realize. His electrician compounded the issue by miswiring and haughtily dismissing my concerns, so no pump overrun. The plumber trusted him implicitly but mistakenly. These are not trivial mistakes in my book.

I don't really think it is the boilers fault!! Its abuse!

smokebox

Based on this new information, the installer does not understand how to wire up a heating system. He therefore used an electrician to wire it for him.

The electrician apparently did not bother or know that wiring the pump to the boiler is required to provide the over run.

If the boiler is running at full power and the demand ceases and water flow stops then all the heat in the combustion chamber is transferred into the now static water in the low water content heat exchanger tube, it flashes to steam ( making a bumping noise ) and the further heat increases the temperature to several hundred degrees at which the metal softens and deforms.

The conclusion is that your installer is under qualified/experienced as previously pointed out, and the electrician had no understanding of heating system requirements.

A combination of their failings resulted in a damaged heat exchanger. I now agree that they are jointly responsible.

Without interviewing them its difficult for me to apportion blame, but perhaps 70% to the electrician?

Some might say 100% to the electrician. But I feel that a heating installer SHOULD understand the basic wiring requirements and have supervised and checked the electrician's work before commissioning.

Tony
 
First, you are right .There is additional gear - in fact a VR61 and VR81 (in upstairs zone).
The VR61 is near the boiler and zone valves . As opposed to the VR65 it allows separate control of 2 CH zones, and a single DHW zone.
Thanks for drawing my attention to the VR61; I wasn't aware of it.

My understanding of radiator output power is based on fairly standard figures of 75C flow and 65C return thus giving a notional mean of 60C.
I think you intended to write "70C" mean!

The next assumption is the room temp of 20C hence the Delta 50 banded about. ie difference between rad mean and room temp. The so called 75,65,20 system for quoting output rates. these are rarely perfectly accurate, as there is no such real thing as a mean radiator plate temperature, but it is a start.
They are accurate when the rad outputs are measured under the controlled conditions laid down in BS EN442. "Mean" rad temperatures is a simplification as it's the actual flow and return temperatures which are significant. A "1000W" rad will give out 980W when the temperatures are 80/60 and 930W at temperatures of 90/50.

If the room is colder we will have a larger delta T and higher outputs. likewise outputs differ if radiator means are changed, as they always are by eg TRVs or boiler flow temp, pump flow etc. This relationship is not linear and I have a delta T table of correction factors that Agile will know all about. I rarely use it!
I hope I have this correct?
Yes that's correct. The table of correction factors is also a simplification as it makes assumptions. The formula similar to this:


It's not 100% correct as the constant should be 49.83. T1 is the flow temp, T2 Return Temp and Tr is Room temp. n is a constant which depends on size and type of rad; it's about 1.3.You divide the nominal output by the calculated value to give the actual output

I reasoned I could run the radiators cooler, and obtain better and lower average return temps. While reasonable condensing will occur at 50 or even 55*C returns , benefits are actually considerably enhanced at even lower return temps.
The range of outside temperatures you want to cater for is important If you are running with a flow of 70C when it is -5 outside, what flow temp will you need when it is 15 outside and can the boiler provide this. Also can the boiler modulate low enough.

I am getting surer and surer I will probably need a bigger but still modulating circulation pump. I don't think the installer took the very high boiler flow resistance and length of pipe runs into account.
Regrettably that is probably true. Most installers just do not realize the effect modern heat exchangers have.

I did some calculations on my system and found that the index circuit is 1.61m with the boiler resistance of 0.71m. The new boiler I am proposing to install has a resistance of 4m, so the index circuit immediately increases to 4.9m. At present I have a UPS 15-50. The Grundfos recommended pump for the new boiler is a Magna 25-60. Fortunately, like you my house is well insulated and the rads on average 90% oversized. So I can easily run the system with a 20C differential, which almost halves the flow rate and reduced the head considerably..

Do you think it will be feasible to run boiler flow below 70C?
Don't see why not. There may be the odd day when the outside temperature is so low that the boiler has to run at a higher temperature. As you have weather compensation you will be able to play around with the curve to get the optimum settings.

Also could you comment on my solenoid valve bypass scheme?!!
I can see what you are trying to do, but can't work out how it would be connected. The solenoid valve only needs to open if all zone valves are closed. A relay could do this, but you need to make sure that there is no back-feed between the zone valves.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top