Concentration camps

[mdf290]

Didn't see it.

..and now you have seen it?

 

[joe-90]

No.

 

[mdf290]

No.

So if we were to agree that for arguments sake 1 million Jews had perished one way or another as a result of this movement then your argument would not be that there was a deliberate attempt to ethnically cleanse but that in fact your argument actually boils down to 2 core points.

1. That 6 million is an overestimation.

2. That gas chambers did not exist.

You cannot argue that 'The Hollocaust' did not exist as that is a subjective term used to describe the deliberate attempt to create a final solution for the Jewish population.

All you can actually argue about is the final figures and whether their method of demise was in fact by gas chambers.


Considering the above . . . is it really worth arguing about.
1,000,000 people lost their lives at least all you want to argue about is not whether the inhumanity took place but the degree of inhumanity.

Not really worth raking up coals for is it?

 

[joe-90]

I'm not disputing that it happened. It's just not 12 million.
Gross exaggeration is what I'm disputing, and the methodology.
It seems to me that the deaths were from typhus - not systematic gassings.
Remember - no holocaust - no state of Israel.

 

[alumni]

Name calling won't make you right.

Now just WHERE did you put the equivalent people of 25 cities the size of Liverpool or Manchester? How can you lose that many people? Where are they?

Just post up the link you base your accusation on.

You can't, because no such claim was made. So it seems you do base your argument on false claim and lies. Nice one.

Shame you haven't got the common decency to accept it.

 

[joe-90]

Name calling won't make you right.

Now just WHERE did you put the equivalent people of 25 cities the size of Liverpool or Manchester? How can you lose that many people? Where are they?

Just post up the link you base your accusation on.

You can't, because no such claim was made. So it seems you do base your argument on false claim and lies. Nice one.

Shame you haven't got the common decency to accept it.

http://www.nizkor.org/

 

[alumni]

You cannot argue that 'The Hollocaust' did not exist as that is a subjective term used to describe the deliberate attempt to create a final solution for the Jewish population.

Unfortunately, for him, when asked if the holocaust did happen his reply was
"dunno".

Hardly a yes is it.

 

[mdf290]

I'm not disputing that it happened. It's just not 12 million.
Gross exaggeration is what I'm disputing

I don't think anyone on here has mentioned 12,000,000 other than yourself.

If you want to argue against your own overestimation then feel free.

Odd behaviour but hey..

 

[joe-90]

That's because I have an open mind on the subject. You should try it sometime.

 

[joe-90]

I'm not disputing that it happened. It's just not 12 million.
Gross exaggeration is what I'm disputing

I don't think anyone on here has mentioned 12,000,000 other than yourself.

If you want to argue against your own overestimation then feel free.

Odd behaviour but hey..

http://www.nizkor.org/

 

[alumni]

Name calling won't make you right.

Now just WHERE did you put the equivalent people of 25 cities the size of Liverpool or Manchester? How can you lose that many people? Where are they?

Just post up the link you base your accusation on.

You can't, because no such claim was made. So it seems you do base your argument on false claim and lies. Nice one.

Shame you haven't got the common decency to accept it.

http://www.nizkor.org/

And still you fail to do so.

Come on, be the big man you claim to be and show where i made the claim.

Then admit you got it wrong - yet again.

 

[joe-90]

Name calling won't make you right.

Now just WHERE did you put the equivalent people of 25 cities the size of Liverpool or Manchester? How can you lose that many people? Where are they?

Just post up the link you base your accusation on.

You can't, because no such claim was made. So it seems you do base your argument on false claim and lies. Nice one.

Shame you haven't got the common decency to accept it.

http://www.nizkor.org/

And still you fail to do so.

Come on, be the big man you claim to be and show where i made the claim.

Then admit you got it wrong - yet again.

http://www.nizkor.org/ You ask Peaps.

 

[mdf290]

I'm not disputing that it happened. It's just not 12 million.
Gross exaggeration is what I'm disputing, and the methodology.

So we have there an agreement that the Hollocaust existed.

and you don't see that being herded off to camps to die in unsanitary conditions was not remarkably convenient...and coincidentaly the fulfilment of the objective by 'back door' means.

 

[joe-90]

I'm not disputing that it happened. It's just not 12 million.
Gross exaggeration is what I'm disputing, and the methodology.

So we have there an agreement that the Hollocaust existed.

and you don't see that being herded off to camps to die in unsanitary conditions was not remarkably convenient...and coincidentaly the fulfilment of the objective by 'back door' means.

Typhus was the killer - it affected the guards too.

Tell me why - if they were death camps - did they keep the typhus victims alive?

 

[alumni]

You ask Peaps.

I'm asking you.
You made the claim, you explain why!!!

Based on posts on this thread. Joe-90 bases his position on lies and misinformation and refuses to explain why.

Don't suppose it would go down too well at the Supremacists Arms if you did admit it eh Joe?[/b]