Quite, as I often observe, he is (very justifiably) highly respected because of his knowledge and communication skills but, given that, it somewhat worries me that he often makes very strong, unqualified and often 'blanket', assertions, quite often based on his own opinions and/or interpretation - which, because of his reputation, many may may take to be absolute/'gospel' truths.
Well I am not totally in disagreement with your statement John.
However, blanket statements do have their use too.
A blanket statement such as a rule that that should be followed 99% of the time (for example) can be a very good thing indeed.
Without crossing all the I`s and Tee`s of a stiuation a good rule of thumb can be made without caveats, otherwise these statements can go on and on and on to cover every eventualatity and becomes quite a ramble ("Oh Ebee, do you not ramble?" I hear some say.)
In fact I think I suggested a blanket statement sort of approach regarding extensions thru letterboxes.
I think that it pretty much holds true because of the seen/unseen potential for danger. That does not mean that I categorically think that they are always potentially dangerous for all persons in all situations, including one or two members of this forum who could well successfully mitigate such potential risks to a very acceptable level. However the easy answerwas a blanket statement.
"Quite, as I often observe, he is (very justifiably) highly respected because of his knowledge and communication skills"
Yep I agree with that. Even though I think that he strongly disagrees with me on some aspects regarding the Ring Final Circuit.
In this forum we have some highly skilled Electricians amongst others highly skilled in their own trades/occupations etc etc instead of or as well of too.
We have some DIYers of various ability and some "ordinary" members of the public too.
I think we should be very mindful of our audiance and the blanket statement/ rule of thumb can serve very very well at most times.
Example - "What Voltage is Dangerous" along with answers like "It`s not volts but amps that kill you!" (I think that is a very stupid statement actually!
Well my answer would be "Zero volts (or very near it)" as a blanket statement.
Then I might further add that 70v or thereabouts might be when it often becomes dangerous (in normal dry conditions), Therefore 50v and less might be relatively safe in normal dry conditions but it all depends on the person and on the day and whether electric shock becomes electrocution in some cases and whether or not an involuntary rapid, high magnitude, twitch on a ladder at the top of the stairway becomes lethal or not.
I think the blanket statement is the most useful in this context.
A blanket statement often has its place and I commend it to the forum.
(Phew! Did I mention that I sometimes have been known to ramble on a bit?
)