Vive La France!

[noseall]

They are required to form an opinion in good faith that the abortion meets the lawful criteria for legal exemption. Nothing more

Nothing? You mean they don't need to sign and date the HSA1 form, thus approving the abortion.
Are you suggesting that if they don't approve the abortion they are not culpable?

 

[noseall]

Why do you think there is a consultation process by two doctors ? Nothing in the act says they are required to examine or even meet the woman.

I never said they did. Why do you insist on posting irrelevant nonsense that is nothing to do with the debate?

The doctors role in approval is explicit, important and considered unlawful if the terms of their role, are not met. The doctors can be prosecuted.

 

[motorbiking]

QUOTE="noseall, post: 5694861, member: 28558"]
In terms of whether at the end of the two doctors consultation process and their ultimate approval - yes.
[/QUOTE]

You literally Just did.

 

[motorbiking]

Nothing? You mean they don't need to sign and date the HSA1 form, thus approving the abortion.
Are you suggesting that if they don't approve the abortion they are not culpable?

What offence are you suggesting they are culpable of ? Offences against the person act ?

 

[noseall]

Just want you to quote the text you claim is in the abortion act.

But you can’t. I wonder why.

I have shown you the wording in the Act multiple times, but you refuse to look at the role of the two doctors, for some bizarre reason.

 

[noseall]

What offence are suggesting they are culpable of ?

If they don't act in good faith?

 

[Notch7]

It explicitly states they must approve, does it?

Strawman argument.

The word approval does need to be explicitly stated, the act of signing is approval

 

[noseall]

Strawman argument.

The word approval does need to be explicitly stated, the act of signing is approval

Correct.

 

[Notch7]

But you said it explicitly states they must approve.

Where does it say this.

Or maybe it doesn’t.

Signing is the act of approval

 

[blup]

Happy St Patricks Day

 

[Notch7]

Still no laws quoted referencing the need for doctors, to approve the abortion

Another strawman

I’m sure the forum trolls tried very hard to find some

Calling people trolls because they disagree with you (because you are wrong) is a tiresome Ad hominem.

 

[carmanmemoranda]

Strawman argument.

The word approval does need to be explicitly stated, the act of signing is approval

And he says he is a lawyer.

 

[motorbiking]

Strawman argument.

The word approval does need to be explicitly stated, the act of signing is approval

When a witness signs as a witness on a Will. They are approving the content ? Righto

 

[Notch7]

When a witness signs as a witness on a Will. They are approving the content ? Righto

Doctors signing the form aren’t witnesses.

 

[noseall]

What offence are you suggesting they are culpable of ?

If they don't act in good faith?