On a related point there was reference to the garden being a special location. If portable equipment and cables fell under BS7671 then logically would you have to notify Building Control when you run an extension lead for your hedge trimmer etc?
The garden is a special location where I live, as is the kitchen, but Part P refers to fixed, so an extension lead in kitchen would not need notifying, but use some cable clips to get it out of the way, and it does need notifying.
But Part P and BS 7671 have nothing to do with each other, Part P is law, BS 7671 is not law, but may be used in a court of law. There are errors with BS 7671, when the rules for RCD protection came out, there was nothing to say it related to low voltage only, so reading the regulation it was also required for extra low voltage, with separated extra low voltage it was pointless fitting a RCD, and at 12 volt they simply would never work.
Some times common sense needs to be used, and a socket like this
is better outdoors than a socket like this
I am not talking about either being in the elements.
This has been the standard way to provide power for caravans and narrow boats for years, OK it seems now they want a linked isolator, I have often thought they are a bit exposed to the elements, but they seem to survive, father-in-law had a 13 amp socket on the wall for his motor caravan which was OK with nothing plugged in, there was a flap, but he left the motor caravan plugged in all the time he was home, and in spite it seeming to lack protection he never did have any problem with it, but I know also no RCD in the house anywhere, he insisted I fit them to protect his grandchildren, be he never fitted them.
The under the control of ordinary person. Well "
Skilled person. A person with technical knowledge or sufficient experience to enable him/her to avoid dangers which electricity may create." so if some one fits a socket then suppose they are not ordinary person? "
Ordinary person. A person who is neither a skilled person nor an instructed person." if an electrician fits a item in some ones house then the occupants would be looked at as ordinary, but if DIY then are they ordinary?
It just gets silly. I am sure the writers of BS 7671 never expected people to dissect it like this, it does need some common sense.