Hate Crime

  • Thread starter Deleted member 221031
  • Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sex is assigned at birth.

Sex is not "assigned "

It is a fact.

It is determined and recorded.

No fairy says "I think today I'll assign all of them to the female list"

Very very infrequently, there is an abnormality or an error.

Trans people are generally not those who suffered a physical abnormality at birth.
 
Sponsored Links
Again all yu are doing is illustrating that you have an ideological belief that transgender people cannot and should not be allowed.

This is a lie you have made up in an attempt to blacken my name.
 
What's not correct?
Stop being vague and ambiguous and state your argument clearly and precisely.
The Gender recognition act recognised the metal illness that is gender dysmorphia and made provision for those suffering from the mental illness to assume the opposite gender in most elements of society and law. It doesn’t allow them to change their sex. The equalities act allows exclusive services etc for sex provided they can be justified. Therefore it’s lawful to restrict women only services from trans-women. Stonewall etc. want the gender recognition act to allow you to be as if biologically female when you remain male. Their poor advice has resulted in at least one case of unlawful discrimination.

See a summary in your favourite lefty paper

 
Sponsored Links
The Gender recognition act recognised the metal illness that is gender dysmorphia and made provision for those suffering from the mental illness to assume the opposite gender in most elements of society and law.
Does the act say "mental illness"?
 
In current Transactivist usage, "Gender" refers to the whim or fantasy of the moment, needing no supporting facts and no consistency
Any evidence to support your theory?
Or is your theory based on a whim or fantasy of yours?
 
This thread is doing well. I’m surprised it’s not locked yet
 
Sex is not "assigned "
It is a fact.
It is determined and recorded.
Of course the label is assigned.
Do you think babies are born with the lable attached by some omnipotent being?
The sex is determined by the attendant at the birth. It is sometimes not obvious and a best guess has to be made.
This is done on a visual inspection, nothing more.

No fairy says "I think today I'll assign all of them to the female list"
Why do you feel the need to resort to petty fantasy?
Is it because your arguments are so weak?
If you had a compelling argument, you wouldn't feel the need to be so silly.

Very very infrequently, there is an abnormality or an error.
You're grasping at straws now, and imposing your own hopeful guesswork on the figures.
One study, over a 18 month period, found that about 0.13% of babies were born with ambiguous genitalia. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6532673/
That, as a comparative percentage of the UK population, is about 86,000
Now let's extrapoloate that to say 80 years. (the current average life span in UK) There are about 53 18 month periods in 80 years. So now let's calculate the number of people who were born with ambiguous genitalia over 80 years: 86,000 X 53 = about 4,500,000.
Not so infrequent now is it? And that's just in the UK!
So taking the population of the UK, there could be as many as 4,500,000 people who were born with ambiguous genitalia. That's nearly 7% of the population, based on a 80 year life span.
And you want to deny these people from living their lves to the fullest extent. You want to deny these people a contented life, to hound them and denigrate them because you have an ideological objection to their existence.

Another study has estimated that about 1 in every 5000 births there is a case of ambiguous genitalia.

Trans people are generally not those who suffered a physical abnormality at birth.
You have no data to support your fantasy. It's only your fantastical hopeful guesswork,

So would you like to present some figures to support your fantastical hopeful guesswork?

Here's some more real data.
Here’s what we do know: If you ask experts at medical centers how often a child is born so noticeably atypical in terms of genitalia that a specialist in sex differentiation is called in, the number comes out to about 1 in 1500 to 1 in 2000 births. But a lot more people than that are born with subtler forms of sex anatomy variations, some of which won’t show up until later in life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sponsored Links
Back
Top