Frexit

  • Thread starter Deleted member 221031
  • Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
According to Roy Bloom.
Every white Brit has 30% German DNA .
I pointed out that ethnic DNA is not evenly distributed throughout the British Isles .
Maybe Southern or Eastern England could have relatively high levels of so called Germanic DNA but in other areas it could be virtually non existent.
Have a browse through the phone book at the distribution of names. It's surprising how many names from a similar origin remain within a 20 mile radius. A few years ago they did a dna test around the village of Cheddar to see if anyone was related to the Neolithic man found buried in one of the caves and found an astonishing number were. Place names are also a good indicator of origin, and especially names for local landmarks.
 
Sponsored Links
According to Roy Bloom.
Is he still on here? Like his previous incarnations is he still suffering from French mentionitis? Is he slipping up and talking in euros and kilometres? Using terms like 'over there' when talking about the UK? Frothing at the mouth about racial inequality yet? He normally implodes when he gets to that stage. If not, perhaps he's learning from past mistakes although I doubt it.
 
Have a browse through the phone book at the distribution of names. It's surprising how many names from a similar origin remain within a 20 mile radius. A few years ago they did a dna test around the village of Cheddar to see if anyone was related to the Neolithic man found buried in one of the caves and found an astonishing number were. Place names are also a good indicator of origin, and especially names for local landmarks.
According to the latest studies the vast majority of people in the British Isles are of pre Celtic stock with some admixture from Vikings ,Norman's ect.
 
According to the latest studies the vast majority of people in the British Isles are of pre Celtic stock with some admixture from Vikings ,Norman's ect.
I don't doubt it. Science has been running around to prove all manner of origins when the relevant information has been there all along. Genealogy can go so far in maintaining a family tie to the region where you're from and dna will establish the science from the known facts of those origins. Australian Aborigines insisted for decades they'd been on the continent for 100,000 years and it wasn't until recent genetic mapping it turned out they were more or less correct.
 
Sponsored Links
Germany didn't become a nation state until 1871.
Irrelevant, as already pointed out.
Read the article carefully, especially this phrase: "the ancestors of modern-day Germans"

The 'average Brit' doesn't have 30% Germanic DNA.
The article did not refer to the average Brit. Read the article carfully, especially this bit: "most white British people"

The Romans, Vikings and Normans may have ruled or invaded the British for hundreds of years, but they left barely a trace on our DNA, the first detailed study of the genetics of British people has revealed.

The analysis shows that the Anglo-Saxons were the only conquering force, around 400-500 AD, to substantially alter the country’s genetic makeup, with most white British people now owing almost 30% of their DNA to the ancestors of modern-day Germans.


Britain is made up of different ethnic groups .
Have a look at a genetic map of the British Isles.
Read the article carefully, especially the bit about other 'immigrants' to the UK:
"The Romans, Vikings and Normans may have ruled or invaded the British for hundreds of years, but they left barely a trace on our DNA, the first detailed study of the genetics of British people has revealed."

If you insist on raising issues that the article has already dealt with, that proves that either you refuse to read the article, or you're failing to understand what you're reading.
 
50% DNA from each parent means 25% DNA from each grandparent.
So if you claim everyone in Britain is 30% German, then everyone should have close German relatives.
Your understanding of maths and DNA is at fault.
Your model relies on one parent with a low percentage of Germanic DNA reproducing with another of little or no Germanic DNA.

If your GGGGGgrand parents had 100% Germanic DNA, your GGGGgrand parents will also have 100% Germanic DNA, not 50% as your model shows.
But DNA inheritance doesn't work like that.
It's hapazard and random.

Concepts – Calculating Ethnicity Percentages
 
Is he still on here? Like his previous incarnations is he still suffering from French mentionitis? Is he slipping up and talking in euros and kilometres? Using terms like 'over there' when talking about the UK? Frothing at the mouth about racial inequality yet? He normally implodes when he gets to that stage. If not, perhaps he's learning from past mistakes although I doubt it.
Are you trying to remind us that your ears and eyes are still closed to anything that disproves your world view?
 
According to the latest studies the vast majority of people in the British Isles are of pre Celtic stock with some admixture from Vikings ,Norman's ect.
Show us any number of these studies.
 
50% DNA from each parent means 25% DNA from each grandparent.
So if you claim everyone in Britain is 30% German, then everyone should have close German relatives.

Your post is such nonsense that I will pay you the compliment of saying you must be doing it deliberately.
 
It isn't telling us anything we didn't already know...

Leslie_et_al_Figure_300crop_copy1.jpg


ucl.ac.uk

I have a much read copy of 'The Celts' written by Nora Chadwick and one of the maps is very similar to the one published above in a study conducted in 2015:

An international team, led by researchers from the University of Oxford, UCL and the Murdoch Childrens Research Institute in Australia, used DNA samples collected from more than 2,000 people to create the first fine-scale genetic map of any country in the world. Their findings, published in Nature, show that prior to the mass migrations of the 20th century there was a striking pattern of rich but subtle genetic variation across the UK, with distinct groups of genetically similar individuals clustered together geographically.

By comparing this information with DNA samples from over 6,000 Europeans, the team was also able to identify clear traces of the population movements into the UK over the past 10,000 years. Their work confirmed, and in many cases shed further light on, known historical migration patterns.


The term 'Celt' is a 19th century definition that broadly groups Cornish, Welsh, Scots and Irish into a big bowl and stirs up a genetic soup to satisfy the tastes of Nationalists in the era when those nations were close to losing their character through English domination.
DNA testing doesn't tell the whole story and other influences like art, poetry and literature should be taken into consideration. It's a bit like describing the treasure trove found in a lake at Neuchatel and lumping the whole lot under the name 'La Tene' to describe the various tribes and clans that had distinct identities at the time.
 
It isn't telling us anything we didn't already know...

Leslie_et_al_Figure_300crop_copy1.jpg


ucl.ac.uk

I have a much read copy of 'The Celts' written by Nora Chadwick and one of the maps is very similar to the one published above in a study conducted in 2015:

An international team, led by researchers from the University of Oxford, UCL and the Murdoch Childrens Research Institute in Australia, used DNA samples collected from more than 2,000 people to create the first fine-scale genetic map of any country in the world. Their findings, published in Nature, show that prior to the mass migrations of the 20th century there was a striking pattern of rich but subtle genetic variation across the UK, with distinct groups of genetically similar individuals clustered together geographically.

By comparing this information with DNA samples from over 6,000 Europeans, the team was also able to identify clear traces of the population movements into the UK over the past 10,000 years. Their work confirmed, and in many cases shed further light on, known historical migration patterns.


The term 'Celt' is a 19th century definition that broadly groups Cornish, Welsh, Scots and Irish into a big bowl and stirs up a genetic soup to satisfy the tastes of Nationalists in the era when those nations were close to losing their character through English domination.
DNA testing doesn't tell the whole story and other influences like art, poetry and literature should be taken into consideration. It's a bit like describing the treasure trove found in a lake at Neuchatel and lumping the whole lot under the name 'La Tene' to describe the various tribes and clans that had distinct identities at the time.
I like this one better.

IMG_5373.jpeg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sponsored Links
Back
Top