TV in bathroom - regs and safety

Sponsored Links
Why is local isolation needed for an alarm system?

We have had a few instances where alarm engineers would not change there panels as they could not isolate the panel supply and its also a specific requirement for fire alarms. though a key switch is now the required way.

Most fcus for boilers fans etc seem used more for double pole isolation reasons regardless of whether on a 6 amp or 32 a circuit, before the days of fan isolater switches they seemed a lot more common.
 
We have had a few instances where alarm engineers would not change there panels as they could not isolate the panel supply and its also a specific requirement for fire alarms. though a key switch is now the required way.
I suppose I wasn't thinking of commercial installations where it might not be convenient to isolate the circuit.


What about in a house, though?
 
We have had a few instances where alarm engineers would not change there panels as they could not isolate the panel supply

They are idiots then aren't they? Every circuit in a house can be isolated either with a MCB or pulling a fuse.
 
Sponsored Links
Every circuit in a house can be isolated either with a MCB or pulling a fuse.
Flats are a different matter, such as the ground floor with the washing machine socket which remained live even with the CU switched off.
Apparently connected to a circuit in the upstairs flat, and they had been paying for the electricity for years without realising.
Probably still are.
 
There was a comment about historically, "lighting" circuits have always been protected by 5/ 6A devices.

In the 13th Edition (and prior, AFAICT), the rating of 1/.044 (0.96mm²) single and multicore cables was 5A.
In the 14th Edition, the rating of 1/.044 (0.96mm²) single core cables was increased to 13A or 12A twin core (with or without ECC).

Looks like there were big changes in assessment of current-carrying capacity between the editions. Under the 13th, the smallest cable size is matched to the smallest fuse size. Under the 14th, this capacity was upped so that the next smallest fuse size could also be used without upgrading the cable.

Historically, 5A was chosen as a fuse size because the allowance was 100W per fitting (although many chose to fit 150W) and 5A= 12 x 100W at 240V (historically, both floors were wired with one circuit).
 
I suppose I wasn't thinking of commercial installations where it might not be convenient to isolate the circuit.


What about in a house, though?
I have known "engineers" (not just alarm ones) be adamant that they want local isolation for the bit of kit they are working on. They don't want to responsible for isolating a whole circuit in case something has a hissy fit when the circuit is re-energised.

I've had some alarms do this and Sky boxes too.They have both needed resetting before they would work again.
 
What you have been showing me are the regs. The regs are not BS 7671.
o_O

screenshot_1369.jpg


:confused:


What does it say on the front of your copy, Winston - surely it must be the same?



Has it occurred to you the regs may have made another mistake that could be rectified in a future amendment?
Has it occurred to you that to insist something must not be done because it might be removed from the regulations in the future is, shall we say, a little light on rationality?
 
I have known "engineers" (not just alarm ones) be adamant that they want local isolation for the bit of kit they are working on. They don't want to responsible for isolating a whole circuit in case something has a hissy fit when the circuit is re-energised.
Yes, that's fair enough and, as I said, some things are a good idea.

I just don't think it should be a Manufacturer's Instruction if it is not electrically required.

They should state the real reason and then we would know; not pretend things like fans need it.

That leads to stupid suggestions that we can then work on them with the lights on
 
The Live is removed that way, the Neutral remains connected. With the Neutral still connected the circuit is not isolated. ( that is my opinion )

I agree with that.

The modern way for alarms now tends to be a 3 amp fuse module and a double pole key switch module in grid.
 
I didn't say it was not allowed. I said there was never, ever, a reason to do it.
And you were wrong to say that.
Supply needed in loft and there's no accessible "power" circuit.
Or, as I've witnessed recently, supply needed but the power circuit is inaccessible because of the use of the modern crap non-liftable flooring. In this case, to have accessed a "power" circuit, it would have meant making swiss cheese of the flooring in a new build - the cable would have needed to go through half a dozen joists and at least one noggin, and that would have needed quite a lot of holes cutting and fixing up again afterwards.

You can argue as to whether ripping a house apart (or rather, avoiding the need to rip it apart) constitutes a "good" reason, but it IS a reason.
 
And you were wrong to say that.
Supply needed in loft and there's no accessible "power" circuit.
Or, as I've witnessed recently, supply needed but the power circuit is inaccessible because of the use of the modern crap non-liftable flooring. In this case, to have accessed a "power" circuit, it would have meant making swiss cheese of the flooring in a new build - the cable would have needed to go through half a dozen joists and at least one noggin, and that would have needed quite a lot of holes cutting and fixing up again afterwards.

You can argue as to whether ripping a house apart (or rather, avoiding the need to rip it apart) constitutes a "good" reason, but it IS a reason.

Presumably only a small load is required in the loft. Therefore I repeat that there is never, ever, a reason to put a 13 amp socket on the lighting circuit. For a small load you can use a clock connector, a BS546 2 amp socket, or a BS546 5 amp socket.
 
Presumably only a small load is required in the loft. Therefore I repeat that there is never, ever, a reason to put a 13 amp socket on the lighting circuit. For a small load you can use a clock connector, a BS546 2 amp socket, or a BS546 5 amp socket.
What if the item you want to supply has a wall wart power supply? Not all, but some boosters do.

Would you then make up a flying lead with a BS546 plug on one end and a BS1363 trailing socket on the other?
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top